Enjoying this recipe?
Post your creation on Instagram and tag #queenbeemixology or @queenbeemixology!
The Pumpkin Butter Old Fashioned takes the familiar structure of a traditional Old Fashioned and infuses it with warm, autumnal flavor. By combining bourbon with pumpkin butter, maple cinnamon syrup, and aromatic bitters, this cocktail delivers a smooth balance of spice, sweetness, and depth.
It’s a simple yet seasonal spin on a timeless whiskey drink!
This cocktail succeeds because each ingredient adds richness without overwhelming the core identity of an Old Fashioned. The bourbon provides structure, the pumpkin butter brings body and subtle sweetness, and the maple cinnamon syrup adds warmth that complements the fall theme.
Visually, it has a warm amber-orange hue influenced by both the bourbon and pumpkin components. Served in a lowball glass over a large ice cube, the drink maintains clarity and structure.
Step 1: Combine all ingredients into a mixing glass topped with ice. Stir to chill.
Bourbon forms the foundation of the cocktail. Its notes of vanilla, oak, and caramel pair naturally with the pumpkin and maple components, grounding the drink with familiar warmth.
Pumpkin butter adds smoothness and mild sweetness. It brings pumpkin flavor directly into the cocktail and helps create a cohesive body.
When stirred with bourbon and syrup, it blends into the liquid for a soft, rounded finish.
The maple cinnamon syrup contributes seasonal sweetness and a subtle spice note.
The maple adds depth while the cinnamon reinforces the fall theme, blending seamlessly with both the bourbon and pumpkin butter.
Aromatic bitters prevent the drink from becoming overly sweet. They add structure, complement the cinnamon notes, and keep the cocktail aligned with the traditional Old Fashioned profile.
Step 2: Strain the mixture into a lowball glass over a large ice cube.
Step 3: Garnish with a dried slice of orange on the side of the glass.
The dried orange slice clipped to the side of the glass serves as a clean, simple garnish. It provides a soft citrus aroma and visually reinforces the warm color palette of the cocktail.
The Pumpkin Butter Old Fashioned brings the comfort of fall flavors into a cocktail format that stays true to the simplicity of the original.
With its balanced sweetness, smooth texture, and warm spice notes, it’s a drink that suits holiday gatherings, quiet evenings, and any moment where you want something seasonal but still classic.
Post your creation on Instagram and tag #queenbeemixology or @queenbeemixology!
